Showing posts with label investment process. Show all posts
Showing posts with label investment process. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 9, 2018

Tourbillon's Jason Karp on Invest Like The Best Podcast

Jason Karp, founder of hedge fund Tourbillon Capital recently appeared on Patrick O'Shaughnessy's podcast, Invest Like The Best, and he talked about a range of investing topics.  We posted extensive notes from the conversation with the full audio below.


On The Differences Between Public and Private Investing These Days

Years ago, 40-50% of stock market volume came from fundamental allocators.  Today it's less than 10%, so 90% of trading activity is coming from passive, quant, CTAs, risk premium captures, etc.  The vast majority of trading then is not coming from people who are concerned with 'what does this company do?' etc.  This leads to multi-day or even multiyear dislocations.

"The time for convergence between cashflows and the fundamentals of a business and stock price is usually 3-5 years at worst."

He said private companies tapping venture capital can now gain massive scale (i.e. Uber) without even going public.  Over the past 5 years there's been an 'explosion' of capital via VC's etc. 

"I believe the trends of why people allocating so aggressively privates is because the public markets have gotten harder. And people don't want to deal with daily, monthly mark-to-market."

He thinks there's a lot of edge left in private equity and a "more linear relationship between effort and outcome."  While that's applicable to public market investing, your time horizon has to be around 5 years.  But if you or your investors have a shorter horizon, it's less so.


On His Investment Style

"If I can find deep value, where the cashflows are growing, which is extremely rare, then that's the best case scenario.  My primary first variable is: 'are the cashflows growing?' Because growth solves a lot of sins."  If cashflows are growing, you can be wrong on the valuation.

They'll take the price today and instead of doing a DCF, he'll do it in reverse and try to figure out what's priced in today's stock and what would have to happen for it to be worth x.

He says that with deep value stocks, most have problems.  "All the cheap stocks have things that are very, very wrong with them.  So you're inherently in an adverse selection pool to try and find the frog that you can kiss that turns into a prince, when most of them are frogs and you're going to get warts on your face.  I just think there's an easier game to play."

On general investment advice he's learned over the years: "It's very important for you to keep your consumer hat on at all times, and remember that your gut instinct about how you feel about the product and experience... is so important."  He compared it a bit to a Peter Lynch-esque approach.  It helps you spot trends much earlier.


Talking Stocks

He thinks Facebook (FB) and Alphabet (GOOG) are surprisingly cheap given how entrenched they are in your everyday life.  He says FB's Instagram specifically is going to grow like crazy with businesses.  There's highly cyclical companies that are trading at around the same valuations, which is kind of crazy.

3 types of edge in market:  information edge, which is largely gone.  Analytical edge still exists and it's based on how you process information versus others.  Structural edge is where he sees the most opportunity: being able to stomach volatility via long-term holding etc. 

"There's more opportunity than I've ever seen in my career for duration... ever."  He says there's so many stocks that screen poorly and others that screen extremely well and are getting very crowded.

He thinks quality, safe, low volatility stocks are very overextended and then there's others that are more value and a little hairier... the disconnect between fundamental value and where the price is, is the largest he's seen in his career.


Industries To Watch For The Future

Karp feels health and wellness is one of the most interesting places to be doing research both in public and private markets right now.  The megatrend here is people focusing on less processed foods, not caring about brand, mainly just wanting quality products.  He thinks the trend is here to stay because once people find out about all the chemicals in their food and how it affects test animals or humans, there's no turning back.  And a lot of it will be demographics since millennials are so young and already focused on this.

He also feels cannabis is going to be one of the biggest industries in this country in the next 5-10 years.  He says it's much more valuable to be learning about this than crypto.  Many of these stocks will go to zero but many will also go up ten-fold.  As the tipping point has hit with legalization starting to happen, he thinks there will be alpha there.


On Hiring

He says that knowledge and passion are the two most important factors in hiring people.  The first is easy to find, the second's not.  And it's the more important of the two.  You want the people working for you to actually enjoy what they do. 

The third variable is emotional intelligence and it's the hardest to find.  He thinks it's more important than IQ.  It's about the ability to control yourself, have empathy, see other points of view, and rapidly change your opinion.  In the investment industry, these are crucial. 

He hires a lot of athletes due to the competitive nature (something we've heard from Julian Robertson before), and people from military backgrounds due to training.  He's also found mothers to be spectacular due to their perspective on managing people and conflicts.  Instead of looking at a resume, look at what a person has been through or actually done.


Embedded below is the podcast interview with Tourbillon's Jason Karp:



And if you haven't already, be sure to check out Patrick O'Shaughnessy's podcast: Invest Like The Best.


Monday, June 12, 2017

Jim Chanos Interview on Bloomberg

Jim Chanos, founder of hedge fund Kynikos Associates recently sat down with Bloomberg to share his thoughts on markets.

He talks about the macro landscape, how the recent political shift has changed things, and other topics.

Chanos is worried about China because it's a debt driven model.  He thinks they've added trillions to the system.

Turning to US healthcare, Chanos says it's a system designed to be gamed:  "It's a hybrid of socialized and free market healthcare."

He thinks the kidney dialysis business is "headed for difficulties."  DaVita (DVA) seems to be one play that Chanos is short.

Telsa (TSLA) is another company Chanos has been short.  He would cover the short if the company actually began to make money.  They were also short Solar City before it got folded into Tesla.  The company burns a lot of cash (he thinks up to as much as $1 billion a quarter).  The upcoming Model 3 is the big test.

Embedded below is the video of Jim Chanos' Bloomberg interview:



For more recent interviews with prominent investors, be sure to also check out Paul Singer's chat with David Rubenstein.


Paul Singer Chats With David Rubenstein

Paul Singer of hedge fund Elliott Management sat down with Carlye Group co-founder David Rubenstein to chat at Bloomberg Invest New York.

They talk about how Singer founded Elliott, investing, and more.

Elliott manages $34 billion now and started in 1977 with $1.3 million.  Singer was a practicing lawyer at the time but started with friends and family money as he found investing much more enjoyable.

Convertible bond hedging was the first strategy Elliott used for around ten years. (Elliott, by the way, is Singer's middle name).  Over 40 years, Elliott has compounded at 13.5% net.

Embedded below is the video of Singer's chat with Rubenstein:



For more profiles of prominent investors, check out Howard Marks' recent interview with Bruce Karsh.


Howard Marks Interviews Bruce Karsh at Wharton School

University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School has started a Howard Marks investor series where the founder of Oaktree Capital interviews outstanding investors and this time around he's interviewed Bruce Karsh, his co-founder at Oaktree.

They talk about the founding of Oaktree, distressed investing, and a myriad of other topics. 

Embedded below is the video of Howard Marks' interview with Bruce Karsh:



For more from Marks, check out his most recent memo: Lines in the Sand.


Monday, April 24, 2017

Market Strategist Jeff Saut on Gaining Street Smarts

Market strategist Jeff Saut has released his latest weekly investment strategy piece entitled "Street Smarts."  The title sums up exactly what his piece is about as he begins by quoting Confessions of a Street Smart Manager by David Mahoney:

"Some people can have a lot of experience and still not have good judgement. Others can pull a great deal of value out of much less experience. That’s why some people have street smarts and others don’t. A person with street smarts is someone able to take strong action based on good judgement drawn from hard experience. For example, a novice trader once asked an old Wall Street pro why he had good judgement. “Well,” said the pro, “Good judgement comes from experience.” “Then where does experience come from?” asked the novice. “Experience comes from bad judgement,” was the pro’s answer. So you can say that good judgement comes from experience comes from bad judgement."

We've said before that investing is a continual education, you never stop learning.  And while you can read all the investment books out there and learn from the mistakes of others (which is highly beneficial), sometimes you just have to make a mistake yourself to truly learn from it.

Saut's weekly strategy piece "Street Smarts" is embedded below:



You can download a .pdf copy here.


Tuesday, April 18, 2017

Howard Marks: The Truth About Investing

Oaktree Capital's Chairman Howard Marks has put together a slideshow entitled The Truth About Investing which was posted by the CFA Society.  In it, he outlines the nuances of investing and also includes notable quotes from others.

Some highlights include:

"The price of a security  at a given point in time reflects  the consensus of investors  regarding its value.  The big gains arise when the consensus turns out to have  underestimated  reality.    To be able to take advantage of such divergences, you have  to think  in a way that departs from the consensus; you have to think  different and  better.   This goal can be described as “second - level thinking” or “variant perception.”

Also:

"Superior performance doesn’t come from being right, but from being more right  than the consensus.   You can be right about something and perform just average if  everyone else  is right, too.  Or you can be wrong and outperform if everyone else is  more wrong."

As well as:

"To be a successful investor, you have to have a philosophy  and process you believe  in and can stick  to, even under pressure.   Since no approach will allow you to profit  from all types of opportunities or in all environments, you have to be willing  to not  participate  in everything  that goes up, only the things that fit your approach. To be a  disciplined investor, you have to be able to stand by and watch as other people make  money in things you passed on."


Embedded below is Howard Marks' slideshow presentation: The Truth About Investing:



You can download a .pdf copy here.

For more from this investor, be sure to check out his book, The Most Important Thing, which is highly recommended if you found the above insightful.

We've also previously posted Howard Marks' latest memo: Expert Opinion.


Wednesday, April 5, 2017

Chuck Akre's Talk at Google: Three-Legged Stool Investment Construct

Chuck Akre of Akre Capital Management recently had a talk at Google about investing entitled "The Peregrinations of an English Major Trying to Solve the Investment Puzzle."

If you're unfamiliar with Akre, he focuses on finding long-term compounders and runs a somewhat concentrated portfolio.  Here's notes from his talk:


Chuck Akre's Talk at Google

- Reads voraciously to this day.  Cited one of the very first books he liked: The Money Masters.  Also noted that 100:1 in the Stock Market is the book he took the idea of compounding from.  Said he read The Intelligent Investor as well as business biographies.

- What makes a great investment?  "Rate of return is the bottom line of all investing."

- Looks at free cashflow return and focuses on valuation as the key to compounding; buy it right.

- How do they identify investments that will generate above average returns?  "We like to fish in the pond of high return businesses."  Asks: what kind of returns on capital?  What are the net margins?  Thinks an 'average' business returns high single digits.  Cites Mastercard (MA) and Visa (V) with 30% margins.  "What is it about the essence of that business that allows them to earn returns that cause them to have a big bullseye on their back?"

- Three-legged stool:  Their investment construct that lets them think in simple terms.  First leg is the quality of a business: a high return business.  Second leg is operations: want management to have skill and integrity (a demonstrated record) and treat investors as partners.  Third leg is reinvestment: would love the company to put cash back into the business if there's great opportunity.  Cited the book Dear Chairman (which we've reviewed here).

- "I have never been able to learn from other people's mistakes.  I have to make my own."

- Wants to be an investor in a business rather than a speculator in shares.

- His goal is to compound capital at an above average rate while incurring a below average level of risk.  Volatility is only a risk in the short run.

- Akre's separately managed accounts over 27 years have compounded at 12.7% versus S&P at 9.4%.  Also has a partnership that's done 15.25% versus S&P 9.2% and mutual funds that have done 13.2% annual.

- Mastercard: originally purchased in 2010 at around $22 with regulatory worries around Durbin amendment.  Business has fantastic returns, had a low valuation (13-14x at the time).  "Their returns are so high they can't possibly find a place to reinvest their money, so our compounding is diminished modestly because of that."

- Moody's (MCO): Bought in January 2012 at $39.  Any company that wants debt has to get a rating on it and it's basically an oligopoly: MCO, S&P (SPGI), and Fitch.

- Enstar (ESGR): Been involved for 10 years.  They buy insurance that's in run-off.  Paid 3 times book when he bought shares. 

- Quotes Einstein: "You should make everything simple as possible but no simpler."  "We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we use to create them."  "The only source of knowledge is experience."  "Imagination is more important than knowledge."  That last quote is what's on the front of Akre's book:

- Two of his best investments (100 baggers): Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A) and American Tower (AMT).  "Most of the time you can buy these businesses at reasonable valuations... sometimes you can buy them at a steal."

- On selling: "The most difficult thing to do in our business is not sell, if you're a long-term investor."

- Bought Visa (V) because they have concentration limits in their funds and were bumping into that with their stake in MA.  Did the same with SBA Communications (SBAC) as it relates to their AMT position.  Gaining more exposure to the themes via competitors since individual position limits kicked in.

Embedded below is video of Chuck Akre's talk at Google:



We've covered many other investor talks at Google, including:

- Howard Marks' talk at Google

- Michael Mauboussin's talk at Google

- Jim Grant's talk at Google


Joel Greenblatt's Talk at Google

Joel Greenblatt is the founder of Gotham Capital and also author of the book The Little Book That Beats the Market.  He recently gave a talk at Google and here are the takeaways:


Joel Greenblatt's Talk at Google

- He thinks the vast majority of investors should index rather than pick stocks.  That said, he doesn't index and Warren Buffett doesn't either.

- Greenblatt said people are still crazy (human behavior) and the market has wild rides (50% drops in recessions, tripling in value afterwards, etc).  So there's an opportunity.  The key is obviously to buy when valuations are below average and sell when they're above average.

- He tells his MBA students at Columbia Business School: "If they do good valuation work, I guarantee the market will agree with them... I just don't know when."

- "Stocks are ownership shares in businesses."  Looks at how relatively cheap they are compared to other businesses, to history, etc.  Measure in absolute and relative value.

- Emphasizes being patient; market oscillates back and forth over the years.  Time horizons are shrinking so we're playing time arbitrage. 

- "Almost never have I bottom-ticked a stock."  That means most of the time he'll be down on a stock at some point.  There's two reasons why: he's either wrong or just needs more time for the thesis to play out.

- Greenblatt also wrote a book called The Big Secret that he joked is still a secret since no one read it.  But he's also authored a wildly popular investing book with a cheesy title: You Can Be a Stock Market Genius

- "To beat the market you have to do something different."

- Runs 100% net long but it's typically achieved via 170% long and 70% short.  They determined the leverage amount based on returns.

- The market's been cheaper 83% of the time based on current valuations.  Based on this, market could see 3-5% returns over the next year and then 8-10% over the next two.  Not a prediction though he said.

- "Stock investing is figuring out what a business is worth and paying less."

- Harped on the importance of compound interest tables.  Start investing as early as possible.

- Thinks there's still a lot of groupthink going on.  If you're good at taking 'unfair bets' in obscure places that other people aren't looking, you can do well.  But eventually you'll have too much money to play in that arena anymore to have it move the needle.

- On Apple (AAPL): "I think it's cheap relative to other choices right now."

- "Your job is to be cold and calculating, and unemotional.  Unfortunately, people are human.  That's good news for us, but the stats are against you."

- "The last man standing is patience.  We call it time arbitrage.  That's in really short supply.  It's not getting better, things are moving faster... and less patience." 

- For more from this investor, we've also posted up Greenblatt's interview with Consuelo Mack

Embedded below is the video of Joel Greenblatt's talk at Google:



We've also posted a bunch of other investor talks at Google, including:

- Howard Marks' talk at Google

- Michael Mauboussin's talk at Google

- Jim Grant's talk at Google


Tuesday, April 4, 2017

Phil Fisher's Investment Checklist: 15 Things to Look For In A Stock

Phil Fisher was a noted investor who founded investment firm Fisher & Company back in 1931.  He was basically a pioneer in the field of growth investing by buying great companies at reasonable prices while focusing on the long-term.  He's also the author of the popular investing book, Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits.

In the book, Fisher outlined what he deemed to be 15 things that investors need to look for in a common stock.


Phil Fisher's Investment Checklist: 15 Things To Look For

1.  "Does the company have products or services with sufficient market potential to make possible a sizable increase in sales for at least several years?"

2.  "Does the management have a determination to continue to develop products or processes that will still further increase total sales potentials when the growth potentials of currently attractive product lines have largely been exploited?"

3.  "How effective are the company's research and development efforts in relation to its size?"

4.  "Does the company have an above-average sales organization?"

5.  "Does the company have a worthwhile profit margin?"

6.  "What is the company doing to maintain or improve profit margins?"

7.  "Does the company have outstanding labor and personnel relations?"

8.  "Does the company have outstanding executive relations?"

9.  "Does the company have depth to its management?"

10.  "How good are the company's cost analysis and accounting controls?"

11.  "Are there other aspects of the business, somewhat peculiar to the industry involved, which will give the investor important clues as to how outstanding the company may be in relation to its competition?"

12.  "Does the company have a short-range or long-range outlook in regard to profits?"

13.  "In the foreseeable future will the growth of the company require sufficient equity financing so that the larger number of shares then outstanding will largely cancel the existing stockholders' benefit from this anticipated growth?"

14.  "Does the management talk freely to investors about its affairs when things are going well but 'clam up' when troubles and disappointments occur?"

15.  "Does the company have a management of unquestionable integrity?"


If you want to explore the usage of checklists further, many investors have recommended Atul Gawande's book, The Checklist Manifesto.  While it's not an investing book, it is about incorporating checklists into your process.

For guidance from other prominent investors, be sure to also check out Viking Global's Andreas Halvorsen on investment process as well as Fairholme Capital's Bruce Berkowitz investment checklist.


Thursday, March 9, 2017

Connor Leonard of Investors Management Corp on Portfolio Construction

Today we're presenting commentary from Connor Leonard of Investors Management Corporation (IMC).  IMC is a holding company located in Raleigh, NC and modeled after Berkshire Hathaway, with the goal of being good long-term owners of excellent businesses.

Connor is the Public Securities Manager for IMC where he runs a concentrated public market portfolio utilizing a value investing philosophy.  While IMC is a privately-held company, they have allowed Connor to share his annual thoughts with Market Folly readers.

Some of his past guest posts over at Base Hit Investing have been featured in our "What We're Reading" links and many readers enjoyed those. 

This letter dives into investment process and portfolio construction and is an excellent read discussing concepts of intrinsic value, variant perception, portfolio concentration, and defining businesses by type of moat.  It's an excellent letter which we'd recommend reading in its entirety.

Embedded below is Connor's annual letter for IMC:







Monday, August 8, 2016

Ten Attributes of Great Investors By Michael Mauboussin

Michael Mauboussin and Credit Suisse have put out a piece entitled "Reflections on the Ten Attributes of Great Investors."  It's basically a clinic on being an investor, it's fantastic.

There are so many quotable passages that you really should just read the whole document.  Each underlying attribute has multiple paragraphs of rationale behind it.  But here's a quick summary:

Mauboussin's 10 Attributes of Great Investors

1.  Be numerate (and understand accounting).

2.  Understand value (the present value of free cash flow).

3.  Properly assess strategy (or how a business makes money).

4.  Compare effectively (expectations versus fundamentals).

5.  Think probabilistically (there are few sure things).

6.  Update your views effectively (beliefs are hypotheses to be tested, not treasures to be protected).

7.  Beware of behavioral biases (minimizing constraints to good thinking).

8.  Know the difference between information and influence.

9.  Position sizing (maximizing the payoff from edge).

10.  Read (and keep an open mind).     


Embedded below is Mauboussin's 10 Attributes of Great Investors:





Mauboussin is an excellent resource for investors looking to refine their approach and process.  We highly recommend his books such as, The Success Equation: Untangling Skill and Luck in Business, Sports, and Investing as well as Think Twice: Harnessing the Power of Countertuition.


Monday, August 1, 2016

Claire Barnes' Investment Philosophy (Apollo Investment Management)

From time to time we highlight various investment approaches by investors.  Here is the investment philosophy by Claire Barnes, Apollo Investment Management.  H/T thefatmargin for the find.


Claire Barnes Investment Philosophy

1.  We value businesses as would a long-term private buyer, and generally ignore the short term views and price influence of other market participants, except in so far as these create opportunities.  In Benjamin Graham's classic analogy, the investor is in business with a manic depressive partner, Mr. Market, who obligingly sets a two-way price every day.  Most of the time, the investor will listen to Mr Market, politely decline to take action, and get on with real life.  Sometimes however, Mr Market's price is wildly in excess of any intrinsic value, and the investor may take these opportunities to sell, perhaps even to retire.  At other times, Mr Market's price is ludicrously low; we have at times in the past been able to buy good businesses with honest management for less than their net cash balances.  At such times, the sober investor will buy, without worrying unduly about whether Mr Market's price may be even lower tomorrow.


2.  We like value - buying a dollar of assets for 50 cents, for example - but never at the expense of quality.  In developed markets, legal protection may (perhaps) be good enough to base decisions on numbers alone.  In Asia, management integrity is paramount.  We also prefer 'operating assets', which generate cash or will do so in future, rather than 'dead assets' reliant on the price someone else may pay.


3.  We like growth as much as value - but "growth at a reasonable price".  One of the easiest mistakes is to overpay for a good company, or a good story.


4.  Given the impossibility of infinite growth on a finite planet, and a suspicion that growth may in future be harder to find, "sustainable income at a reasonable price" is attractive too.


5.  Sustainability is never absolute.  We value resilience.


6.  We seek good businesses: internal returns are important.  Deep value buys may arise from very cheap to somewhat cheap and remain illiquid.  The managers of our holdings do most of the work for us when they continue to generate good returns internally, and this reduces reinvestment risk.


7.  Free cashflow is good; sensible capital allocation is key.


8.  We like dividends - especially in those parts of Asia where there are no tax disadvantages, but anyway it is generally a good idea that excess cash be returned to the shareholders.  (If companies with a good value-adding record want cash for expansion, investors can be relied upon to stump up enthusiastically for a rights issue.)  We dislike buyback-and-issuance schemes designed to enrich insiders, but buybacks shrinking the capital base at discounts to intrinsic value are sometimes constructive.


9.  We try to know our companies inside out.  We visit the companies, try to read their annual reports and announcements from cover to cover, talk to their competitors, and so on.  The longer we've known them, the better.


10.  We don't worry about missed opportunities.  Most companies are too complicated: we look for businesses we like and think we can understand, and focus on relatively few.


11.  We buy securities on a 3-5 year time horizon.  (Maybe even more - ideally we would like to buy good companies at good prices and hold forever, but in an ever more volatile world, 3-5 years may be as far ahead as one can realistically hope to see, and certainly we need to keep reassessing.)  However, if a security appreciates rapidly to the point where it no longer represents reasonable value in absolute terms or relative to prospective purchases, or if new information comes to light which causes us to reevaluate, we may sell with alacrity.  Restraining fund size helps us to maintain selling discipline.


12.  The emphasis has changed slightly over the years, due to changing market conditions and sometimes-painful experience.  Our style will, we hope, continue to evolve:  in a changing world, we see no point in narrowing options unnecessarily.



For more on the investment process of other successful investors, check out:

- Andreas Halvorsen (Viking Global) on investment process

- Seth Klarman's value investing lessons

- Investing lessons from KKR's Henry Kravis

- Donald Yacktman on viewing stocks as bonds 


Thursday, July 31, 2014

East Coast Asset Management on An Ownership Mindset: Q2 Letter

Christopher Begg's East Coast Asset Management is out with its Q2 letter.  In it, Begg outlines the "value of an ownership mindset and how it plays an integral part in a compounding triumvirate with a good business and an effective operator."

Comparing investing to horse racing, he highlights how it's important to ask certain questions:

"If we bought this business in its entirety, could we put blinders on for five or ten years and feel secure in our investment?  Our level of comfort is simplified by the three key factors of business (horse), operational excellence (jockey), and the timelessness of an owner mindset (owner/trainer)."


Embedded below is East Coast's full Q2 letter:



For more from this firm, check out their previous letter on understanding the mispricing of an investment.


Monday, April 21, 2014

Parallels Between Great Investors and a Renowned Sushi Chef: Jiro Dreams of Sushi

At first glance, it may seem odd to compare a sushi chef to an investor.  But as you'll see by the end of this post, they both share a common goal: to become masters of their craft.

Jiro Dreams of Sushi is a documentary about renowned sushi chef Jiro Ono in Tokyo, Japan.  His restaurant, Sukiyabashi Jiro, is a Michelin three-star restaurant, requires reservations a month in advance, and prices start at ¥30,000 (around $300 US).

After watching this insightful documentary, it became glaringly evident that investors and sushi chefs have a lot more in common than one would think.


Parallels Between Great Investors and a Renowned Sushi Chef


1.  Develop a constant, repeatable process.  Jiro does the same thing almost everyday.  He sculpts the pieces of sushi the same way over and over.  He constructs the day's menu and seating chart.  He even boards the daily train from the same exact spot each time.  His attention to detail might seem maniacal to some, but to him, it's a necessity to achieve greatness.

Applied to investing, great capital allocators seek to identify their own 'style' of investing.  Many of the greatest investors develop a repeatable process of finding ideas that meet various criteria.  Instead of being a deep value investor one day and then becoming a momentum trader the next, talented investors seek to find their niche and stick to it over and over and over again.


2.  Never stop learning, pursue perfection.  Jiro talks about how he is always trying to improve despite the fact that he was 85 years old when this documentary was filmed (in 2011).  He wants to be at the top of his game, even though he doesn't know how high up that is.

Jiro's fish vendor says that, "even at my age (50), I'm discovering techniques.  Just when you think you've figured it all out, you realize that you're just fooling yourself."  His shrimp vendor adds, "When you work at a place like Jiro's, you are committing to a trade for life."

The documentary also references 'shokunin' frequently, which literally translated seems to mean 'artisan,' but it sounds like the meaning goes much deeper than that in Japanese culture.  Jiro says that, "Shokunin try to get the highest quality fish and apply their technique to it.  All I want to do is make better sushi.  I do the same thing over and over, improving bit by bit.  There is always a yearning to achieve more."

Likewise, investing is a continual education.  Great investors are always improving and refining their process.


3.  Be passionate about your craft.  Instead of retiring, Jiro is doing what he loves on a daily basis: making sushi and perfecting his art.  He gives his all every single day.  Jiro says, "You have to love your job.  You have to fall in love with your work."

Some investors, like Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger, are getting up there in age but they don't stop.  They love what they do and they come into work each day excited to try to find their next investment and to perfect their art.


4.  Develop a discerning palate.   Jiro says, "The quality of ingredients is important but you need to develop a palate capable of discerning good and bad."  In investing, 'ingredients' can be the various inputs that determine the success of a business, such as the management team.  While that 'ingredient' is important, at the end of the day, you still have to develop a palate that's capable of discerning between a good and a bad business.

As Warren Buffett put it, "When a manager with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact."


5. Be highly selective.  Jiro's vendors are very specific: 1 focused on tuna, 1 for shrimp, 1 for rice; each is the best of their trade.  This is somewhat akin to an investment fund that has analyst teams broken down by sector.  The analysts and sector heads become so immersed in those businesses that they become micro experts.  Jiro trusts these vendors to bring him the best ingredients, and fund managers trust their teams to bring them the best ideas.

There's also a fantastic scene at the Tsukiji fish market where Jiro's tuna vendor comments that, "I either buy my first choice or I buy nothing.  If ten tuna are for sale, only one can be the best.  I buy that one."

This is comparable to focusing on a strict set of criterion each investment must pass before it's added to the portfolio.  An example of this is Mohnish Pabrai, who frequently talks about the importance of an investment checklist.  Extrapolated further, many successful investors have allocated capital only to their best ideas.  As Fairholme Capital's Bruce Berkowitz says, "Why put money in your tenth best idea?" 


6.  Determine the important metrics.  Jiro's eldest son, Yoshikazu, helps run the restaurant and will succeed his father one day.  In the film, he goes to the market to buy some octopus and the vendor points out the color difference between two octopuses.  Yoshikazu doesn't care; he says he's only focused on one thing: the flavor.

In investing, investors need to identify the few key metrics that define and drive a given business.  Once those metrics are identified, it helps the investor really focus on the business' performance.


7.  Learn from a mentor.  A fish vendor says, "When you work for Jiro, he teaches you for free.  But you have to endure ten years of training."  There's a natural progression for employees at Jiro's restaurant from preparation cook to apprentice to a chef who opens their own restaurant.  Jiro is the master and his son, Yoshikazu, is the protégé being groomed to takeover.

On Wall Street, there are many examples of successful mentor/protégé relationships.  In value investing, you have Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett.  In global macro, you have George Soros and Stanley Druckenmiller.  In long/short equity, you have Julian Robertson and all of his Tiger Cubs (John Griffin, Andreas Halvorsen, Lee Ainslie, among many others).

This just goes to show that some of the greatest investors (and sushi chefs) have spent time to learn under the best.  It also reinforces the junior analyst > analyst > sector head > portfolio manager hierarchy that many larger firms employ.  You have to gain valuable experience and learn the necessary skills to succeed in the craft of investing. 


8.  Identify your competitive advantage.  Jiro recognizes his strengths and weaknesses.  Investors should do the same.  Warren Buffett famously says to, "focus on your circle of competence."

There's one particular scene in the documentary where everyone says Jiro's rice is the best.  A hotel wanted to buy the same rice from Jiro's vendor, but the vendor said no because, "what's the use if they don't know how to cook it properly?"

Jiro purchases very specific rice from this vendor and uses a distinct preparation method that involves very high pressure to cook it and requires it to be served at a specific temperature.  He doesn't know anyone else who does this.

Other examples include the fact that his chefs massage the octopus for an hour to make it less tough texturally.  Jiro also plans the progression of the courses in a certain order, something it took him years to refine.  His specific vendors, focus on high quality ingredients, and preparation techniques are some of the things that differentiate him from the competition.

Fund managers these days are often asked by potential investors what their competitive advantage is over other active managers.  Good investors will have identified this and can quickly point it out, whether it be experience, style/strategy, sector focus, time horizon, their limited partners, or a myriad of other factors.


9.  Attention to detail is key.  Jiro is laser focused on every detail of the dining experience at his restaurant.  Before customers arrive, Jiro sets a seating chart in order to enhance the flow of the meal while accommodating groups so they can sit together.  If he notices a customer is left-handed, he immediately adjusts where he is placing the sushi in front of them.  He also alters portion sizes based on whether the diner is male or female.  The presentation of each piece of fish is timed ideally for taste, texture and temperature.  Jiro is very methodical in everything he does.

Attention to detail in investing is key as well.  Just ask hedge fund manager Jim Chanos, who famously identified fraud at Enron by obsessively examining their books.  This is also why so many hedge funds dig so deep on potential investments.

Analysts perform channel checks by visiting countless retail stores, talking with competitors & industry experts, surveying customer preferences, etc.  And don't forget the basics: listening to company conference calls and reading SEC filings (including the fine print) etc.  It's the little things that can make a big difference.


10.  Take advantage when opportunities arise.  Jiro doesn't necessarily have the same menu everyday.  His son sees what the best ingredients are at the market for that day and Jiro molds the menu around it.  In this manner, the fish market is a lot like the stock market.  Advantageous investors scoop up shares of specific companies when they find the prices they're looking for. 

There are other similarities, too.  Jiro and his chefs are familiar with all the ingredients they work with, so they know what is good at any given day at the market and when to strike (this ties back in to developing a discerning palate).

The same can be said for many investors who build a 'universe' of investments they've become familiar with over time from past research.  When a business they like finally trades at a price they're comfortable with, they can buy.



As you can see, there are some interesting parallels between great sushi chefs and great investors.   If you haven't seen it already, Jiro Dreams of Sushi is a well-done documentary worth viewing, especially if you like sushi (just don't watch it hungry).

Embedded below is a trailer for Jiro Dreams of Sushi:



You can purchase a DVD copy here or you can watch via instant video here.

"Always try to improve on yourself.  Always strive to elevate your craft.  That's what he taught me."  ~ Yoshikazu on his father, Jiro


Thursday, July 18, 2013

Intangible Attributes That Lead to Intelligent Investment Decisions: East Coast's Q2 Letter

Christopher Begg is out with East Coast Asset Management's Q2 letter and in it he tackles the intangible attributes that they feel lead to intelligent investment decisions.

Here's a few of the intangibles they've identified:

- Ability to be receptive
- A curious nature
- Desire to seek continuous improvement

Expanding on investment process, Begg writes,

"Freedom from answers is not indecisiveness, it is an awareness of the biases that lead to false convictions where one roots oneself into a position that is immovable.  We are not always right, and humility has taught us to treat every capital allocation decision we make with the assumption that we are unaware of some unknowable piece of information.  Even after we decide to make an investment, we set a course to discover what we missed."

The full letter is below.  For those less interested in process and investment approach, East Coast also lays out their investment thesis for an agricultural equipment manufacturer at the end of the letter:

East Coast's Q2 letter:




For more from this firm, head to East Coast on transformation investments.


Thursday, March 7, 2013

Lessons From Stanley Druckenmiller: Hedge Fund Market Wizards

Legendary investor Stanley Druckenmiller recently came out of the shadows and gave a rare interview on a myriad of topics.  Given the popularity of that post, we thought it'd be interesting to see what lessons we could learn from this great investor so we looked at Druckenmiller's interview in Jack Schwager's book The New Market Wizards to see what we could learn.

Druckenmiller formerly ran hedge fund Duquesne Capital as well as George Soros' Quantum Fund, and he saw annual average returns of 30% since 1986.  He managed around $12 billion before shutting down Duquesne.

A few years ago, he returned Duquesne outside capital and now runs a family office.  Many of his former employees founded PointState Capital with money from Druckenmiller and former Duquesne investors.


Lessons From Stanley Druckenmiller

In Jack Schwager's book The New Market Wizards, Stanley Druckenmiller provides the following bits of wisdom:


On achieving a superior track record:  "George Soros has a philosophy that I have also adopted: The way to build long-term returns is through preservation of capital and home runs ... The way to attain truly superior long-term returns is to grind it out until you're up 30 or 40 percent, and then if you have the convictions, go for a 100 percent year."


On what he's learned from George Soros: "Perhaps the most significant is that it's not whether you're right or wrong that's important, but how much money you make when you're right and how much you lose when you're wrong ... Soros has taught me that when you have tremendous conviction on a trade, you have to go for the jugular.  It takes courage to be a pig ... As far as Soros is concerned, when you're right on something, you can't own enough."


On when to take more risks: "Many managers will book their profits when they're up a lot early in the year.  It's my philosophy, which has been reinforced by Mr. Soros, that when you earn the right to be aggressive, you should be aggressive."


On analyzing companies: "I particularly remember the time I gave (the research director) my paper on the banking industry.  I felt very proud of my work.  However, he read through it and said, 'This is useless. What makes the stock go up and down?' That comment acted as a spur.  Thereafter, I focused my analysis on seeking to identify the factors that were strongly correlated to a stock's price movement as opposed to looking at all the fundamentals.  Frankly, even today, many analysts still don't know what makes their particular stocks go up and down."


On using both valuation and technicals:  "I never use valuation to time the market.  I use liquidity considerations and technical analysis for timing.  Valuation only tells me how far the market can go once a catalyst enters the picture to change the market direction.  The catalyst is liquidity, and hopefully my technical analysis will pick it up."


Learning from mistakes/Trading stories:  The book has too many great stories to list, but one of the main lessons Druckenmiller learned is that you can be right on a market/trade and then still lose your ass if excessive leverage is involved.

Druckenmiller tells numerous stories involving Soros and Paul Tudor Jones.  These tales are really remarkable, including one where he was 130% long the day before the 1987 stock market crash, yet he still was up for that month due to his ability to quickly recognize his error, minimize losses, and reverse his positioning.



Definitely pick up the classic book The New Market Wizards if you haven't read it, as it's full of wisdom from Druckenmiller as well as other traders/investors.


Monday, February 25, 2013

Viking Global's Andreas Halvorsen: Rare Interview on Investment Process

Viking Global's founder Andreas Halvorsen spoke at the Milken Institute where he shares wisdom on investment process and numerous investing topics.  This is a rare opportunity to learn from this hedge fund manager.


On the importance of management teams:  He says that good management teams are extremely underappreciated in their ability to take market share, even in low growth environments.  He equally believes poor management teams are underappreciated in that they can destroy things quicker than you think.


On short selling: "It's a heartwrenching activity, because you can lose a lot of money doing it."  He says you can't short a bunch of underperforming stocks because the risk is too high if you're wrong.  And when you are wrong, "you have to get out very quickly, which means you can't have very large positions."


On Viking's approach to investing: They start by looking at industries/sectors and talking to competitors, suppliers, etc.  He talks with management to see how they think about the competitive dynamics of the industry.  He likes to bet on a management team that has a view of the underlying dynamics similar to what Viking believes.


On hedge fund fees:  He said he is fascinated by investors' focus on fees, arguing that they should instead be focusing on the net return after fees.  While he is obviously biased here since he runs a hedge fund, he make a very good analogy, comparing fees and returns of funds to expenses and revenues of any business: Index funds all have the same revenues (return) while they have different expenses (fees).  Active managers, on the other hand, have both different returns and different fees.  So focusing just on the fees doesn't make sense.



On patience:  Lastly, Halvorsen also harped on the value of having patience. He says you have to have patience in any business, and hedge funds are no different.


This is a fantastic interview and we highly recommend watching it in its entirety.  Embedded below is the video with Viking Global's Andreas Halvorsen:



To see Viking's latest portfolio, check out the brand new issue of our Hedge Fund Wisdom newsletter that was just released.


Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Position Sizing Utilizing the Kelly Growth Criterion

Investing is a continual education and from time to time we like to highlight concepts on refining investment process.  Today we present a piece on position sizing utilizing the Kelly Growth Criterion. 

The following is a guest post from Kyle Mowery, who founded GrizzlyRock Capital in 2011 as a long / short manager investing in corporate debt and equity securities.  He can be reached at kyle@grizzlyrockcapital.com or at www.grizzlyrockcapital.com.


Position Sizing Utilizing the Kelly Growth Criterion  

One of the more vexing tasks for investment allocators is position sizing. Regardless whether allocators select investment managers or individual securities, optimal position sizing is paramount to portfolio success. Small allocations to prescient investments minimize their impact while large allocations to poorly performing investments leads to underperformance.

Some allocators elect to equal-weight investments given uncertainty regarding which investments will perform best. This strategy creates a basket of attractive investments that should profit regardless of which investments in the basket succeed. This method benefits from simplicity and recognizes the future is inherently uncertain. Drawbacks of the strategy include underweighting exceptional investments and overweighting marginal ideas.

Another strategy is to allocate large amounts of capital to the investment ideas with the most potential. This methodology suggests investors should invest proportionally according to their ex-ante return expectations. The advantage of this methodology is matching prospective return to investment size. However, this strategy breaks down when allocators are incorrect about future investment return or risk prospects.

Investment allocators determine their methodology through a combination of portfolio mandate, risk tolerance, and confidence level in investment assessments. While the various approaches implemented are directionally helpful, most are mathematically sub-optimal. There is a better way - the Kelly Growth Criterion.


Kelly Growth Criterion

The Kelly Growth Criterion is a simple formula that determines mathematically optimal allocations to maximize long-term portfolio performance given each investment’s probability of success (“edge”) compared to the amount gained or lost (“odds”). The formula assumes a bimodal outcome of success (“base case”) or failure (“stress case”) over a single time period:


(click to enlarge)

The formula’s power lies in considering both the chance of success and payoff offered. For example the formula would urge a large investment if you had a significant edge given reasonable odds or exceptional odds payoff offsetting a moderate chance of success.


Ok, How Can the Formula be Applied to Investing?

When applied to investing, the Kelly Growth Criterion formula has six inputs. First is simply portfolio size. Second is the amount of capital the portfolio will risk in the pursuit of gain. This amount is also called the maximum tolerable drawdown. For a venture capital group this number will be high while a conservative pension plan would be willing to risk much less. Portfolio size and maximum tolerable drawdown remain constant for each portfolio analyzed regardless of specific investment opportunities.

Next comes four factors regarding the investment itself: the probability of gain in a base case, probability of loss in a stress case, percent of projected gain in the base case, and percent of projected loss in the stress case. The formula is below:



 (click to enlarge)

For example, let’s say we are running a $100 million portfolio of US equities. Our mandate is fairly conservative so let’s assume the maximum portfolio drawdown tolerable to be 15% of assets.

We believe General Electric is attractive but are not sure how to size the position within our portfolio. Our team has agreed that our projected gain in the base case is 12% while we would lose 8% in the stress case. Further, the team has agreed the probability of gain to be 55% (base case) and a 45% probability of loss (stress case). Ok, so how much capital do we allocate to General Electric stock?



(click to enlarge)

Given both a strong “edge” (55% probability of success) and advantageous “odds” (12% projected gain in the base case is greater than 8% projected loss in the stress case), the formula suggests we allocate 3.75% of our portfolio to GE. If the “edge” was even, the formula would recommend a 2.50% allocation – again due to the disproportionate odds of success (12% vs. 8%).

What strikes many allocators initially is the magnitude of the size. Is 3.75% really optimal under a scenario with only a 55% probability of success? Mathematically speaking, yes. Why does this seem high?

The recommended 3.75% investment in GE seems high due to the commonality of diversification by funds and investment allocators. Let’s again work an example with our $100 million fund with a 15% maximum tolerable drawdown. Let’s further assume this fund has 100 investments therefore averaging 1.0% per investment. If an allocator takes the view that the “edge” is a coin flip (i.e. probability of success is equal to probability of failure). What would an allocation of 1.00% imply about the expected “odds”?



(click to enlarge)

As shown above, a 1.00% allocation to a position implies just an 11.54% gain in the base case versus a 10.00% decline in the stress case assuming equal odds. These odds are hardly the makings of a scintillating investment.


Why is the Kelly Growth Criterion Rarely Used for Investment Allocation?

Given the formula is mathematically optimal and simple to implement, one might think allocators would embrace the tool. However, investment allocators are not aware of this tool primarily because academic finance has not fully embraced the tool. Secondly, there are a few key weaknesses of the tool.


How Can Inherent Limitations of the Kelly Growth Criterion Formula be Overcome by Investment Allocators?

(1) Ex-ante input assumptions are inherently precise: As with any model, the formula is only as good as its inputs. How can allocators know beforehand whether an investment has a 50% or 55% chance of success? This input must be estimated without an ability to determine the efficacy of the estimate ex-post facto.

The simplicity and power of the formula is a double-edged sword. If investment allocators systematically overestimate the probability of success, long run return will be hampered. The offset of this risk is to estimate projected gains and success probability conservatively. If allocators error on the conservative side, the model will allocate smaller amounts to each investment. This is perfectly acceptable given the model’s proclivity to encourage substantial position sizes.


(2) The formula cannot account for correlation: The Kelly Growth Criterion accounts for an investment’s specific edge and odds. As such, the formula cannot address the relationship between portfolio investments and thus does not account for correlation.

Ask anyone who invested during 2008, correlations rise during a stress environment. If the probabilities of investment success (“edge”) in a given portfolio are correlated, a portfolio allocated strictly according to the Kelly Growth Criterion would be susceptible to risk factors which increase correlation.

There are two mitigants for this risk: (1) Invest in securities with divergent risk factors. If your edge in each investment is not correlated, the formula will provide a strong outcome at a portfolio level. (2) Akin to the mitigants for imprecise input assumptions, estimating a conservative edge and odds for each investment will decrease position sizing in any one security. By avoiding the weaknesses of the Kelly Growth Criterion, the robustness of the formula is enhanced.


(3) The formula assumes a single time period while portfolios are managed more frequently: The Kelly formula assumes a bimodal outcome, success or failure. Portfolio managers often confront prices that meander towards their eventual outcome over time. As prices change, positions sizing will be suboptimal at various times. To compensate for the model’s simplicity, allocators should specify time horizons before entering a position. For example, if hiring a private equity fund manager with an investment horizon of 10 years your Kelly Growth formula will utilize a much longer time frame than if you manage a trading book.

My firm, GrizzlyRock Capital, utilizes long-term, fundamental value methodology. As such, we utilize a period of multiple years when applying the Kelly Growth Criterion. We calculate the value of a business using an upside, base, and stress case and then utilize the base and stress case forecast in the Kelly formula. This conservatism allows the investment to trend towards our base case without our needing to reassess position sizing using the formula.


Conclusion  

The Kelly Growth Criterion is valuable to investment allocators given the systematic, repeatable process and mathematically optimal portfolio structure. While a practical tool, the formula is not a silver bullet. When used conservatively, the formula will maximize portfolio growth by allocating capital to the most advantageous investments given both prospective return and risk.

Bill Miller of Legg Mason and Ed Thorp of Princeton Newport Partners (now closed) are investors with stellar track records over decades who embrace and advocate the use of the Kelly Growth Criterion in portfolio allocation. In his recent treatise, Antifragile, Nassim Taleb lavishes praise on the Kelly Growth Criterion: “Kelly’s method requires no joint distribution or utility function. In practice one needs the ratio of expected profit to worst-case return – dynamically adjusted to avoid ruin.”

For more detail on the Kelly Growth Criterion, I recommend reading Fortune's Formula by William Poundstone or the Ed Thorp chapter (Chapter 6) in Jack Schwager's Hedge Fund Market Wizards.

At GrizzlyRock, we have found utilizing the Kelly formula eliminates our emotional biases towards certain aspects of investing and provides a stable, repeatable investment allocation of capital.  Please drop me a line at kyle@grizzlyrockcapital.com if you wish to discuss further or be added to our distribution list.

Best of luck implementing the formula at your firm!




Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Bill Ackman on Everything You Need To Know About Investing & Finance In 1 Hour

Pershing Square Capital Management CEO Bill Ackman did a video for Floating University and The Big Think entitled "Everything You Need to Know About Finance and Investing In Under an Hour."


On Finance / Business

The first segment of the video is ideal for beginners and students as it combines concepts from introductory accounting, finance and business classes.  He covers topics such as:

- How business works
- How to raise capital
- How to monetize your business investment
- Dynamics of investing in debt versus equity
- Assessment of risk
- Valuation


On Investing

The second part of the video delves into investing, noting that "the most valuable asset in investing is time."  He highlights the keys to successful investing:

1. Invest in public companies
2. Understand how the company makes money
3. Invest at a reasonable price
4. Invest in a company that could last forever
5. Find a company with limited debt
6. Look for high barriers to entry
7. Invest in a company immune to extrinsic factors
8. Invest in a company with low reinvestment costs
9. Avoid businesses with controlling shareholders

Ackman summarizes things by saying, "Find a business that you understand, has a record of success, makes an attractive profit, and can grow over time."  He says the best investments don't require a lot of reinvestment capital and generate a healthy cashflow to pay out in dividends to shareholders

He also addresses other investing concepts such as compound interest, psychology of investing, and how to withstand volatility

Other takeaways: Ackman said that, "(The) key here is not just shooting for the fences, but avoiding losses."  It's also worth highlighting that Ackman said he became interested in investing when he was 22 as he read The Intelligent Investor by Benjamin Graham.

Embedded below is Bill Ackman's video for Floating University:



We've also posted up a ton of other educational investment info (scroll through the list). 

For more advanced topics, head to more from this hedge fund manager via Bill Ackman's recommended reading list.


Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Are These The Next Warren Buffetts? Wisdom From Klarman, Perry, Chanos & More

Fortune recently republished an article that originally appeared in the 1989 issue of Fortune magazine.  "Are These The New Warren Buffetts?" was written by Brett Duval Fromson and highlights investors from that period who were thought to be talented enough to match the investing acumen of Warren Buffett.  Twenty-plus years later, the article accurately pinpointed some amazing investors.

The article identified the following (at the time) young investors:

- Seeking Subtle Signs of Value: Seth Klarman (Baupost Group)
- The Bargain Hunter: Michael Price (MFP Investors)
- Turning Value Upside Down: Jim Chanos (Kynikos Associates)
- A Formula For Deals: Richard Perry (Perry Partners)
- Pairing Value With Arbitrage: Eddie Lampert (ESL Investors)
- A Freudian Grahamite: Randy Updyke
- The Passionate & The Skeptical: Glenn Greenberg & John Shapiro (Chieftain Capital)
- A Scientist on Wall Street: Thomas Sweeney (Fidelity)
- Mr. Preservation of Capital: John Constable (Constable Partners)
- Mr. & Mrs. Aggressive: Jim and Karen Cramer


Wisdom From The "Next Buffetts"

As you can see, the list highlights some gems.  However, the best part of the article is that each investor shared some rare nuggets of wisdom regarding their approach that we wanted to draw attention to:


Seth Klarman: "Klarman's exceptionally quick and subtle mind allows him to see value in many different guises.  With stocks high, he looks for 'market-insensitive opportunities.'  By that he means companies whose financial performance depends on bankruptcies, announced mergers, liquidations, restructurings, or spinoffs -- corporate events largely independent of the vagaries of the financial markets."  Klarman focuses on the downside, saying: "I focus on what could go wrong.  Before buying, we always ask ourselves, 'what would we pay to own this company forever.' "  For more from this great investor, we've posted up Seth Klarman's recommended reading list.


Michael Price: "I like cheap stocks.  I'm basically a guy who looks at a company's balance sheet and asks, 'what is the company worth? Give me a number.'  If the answer is, 'Substantially more than the price,' then I get interested."


Richard Perry: "His investment approach? E(V) = {P(UPx) + [(1-P) (DPx)]} / (1 + COF).  That simply means he values a deal by calculating the odds that it will go through, how long it will take, and what the investment is worth with and without the deal.  Why all the effort to quantify?  Says Perry: 'There are no lay-ups in the arbitrage business.  This helps us maintain clear, high standards for buying a deal.' "  For more thoughts on this strategy from well-known investors, we've also posted up John Paulson on the risk in risk arbitrage.


Jim Chanos: "Chanos is in truth a perverse kind of value investor.  Using the same techniques as the others, he looks for overvalued stocks.  He stays mainly in large-capitalization issues.  That way there is more liquidity and thus less chance of a short squeeze, which would force him to liquidated his position because he could no longer borrow shares from brokers."  For more on his approach, we've posted up Chanos on the psychology of short selling as well as Chanos on the power of negative thinking.


Eddie Lampert: "Arbitrage helps our value investing.  If we can earn 20% to 25% annualized returns in arbitrage, then for the long term we can buy only stocks that we think will earn comparable rates of return.  Conversely, if deal stocks get overpriced, we will begin investing in companies with good long-term prospects at low prices." 


Randy Updyke: "Investing is about survival.  I stay away from the herd.  I like to buy things for a lot less than I think they are worth.  But to me the psychology and mood of the market are more important than anything."


Thomas Sweeney: "People always panic.  If you study this phenomenon over time, you see that eight times out of ten you make money by buying into a panic."



Be sure to check out the full re-published version of the Fortune article, where you can see Chanos rocking a sweet mustache and other great vintage pictures.